When You’ve Forgotten That You Have Choices

Photos by Magenta School of Magick

From the outside, everything looks seamless. You are meeting deadlines, fulfilling roles, managing expectations and keeping the machinery of your daily life running with practised efficiency. 

Yet beneath the surface of all that productivity, a quiet, unsettling question has begun to whisper: When was the last time I made a choice that was genuinely my own?

It’s one of the great paradoxes of modern life. We rarely wake up one morning and suddenly decide to hand over the steering wheel of decision making to someone else. A boss, a partner, a co-worker….or anyone really.

Instead, we surrender it gradually. It’s one small compromise here, one sensible boundary crossed there until eventually, we become so adept at responding to the world that we forget we have the power to change it.

This is what we mean by the “quiet loss” of personal agency.

Whether you are navigating a personal rut, trying to build a business that actually aligns with your soul, or leading others through uncertain times the underlying emotional exhaustion is remarkably similar. It is the heavy feeling of performing an identity rather than living a life, and wondering if you’ve collected too many of everyone else’s answers at the expense of your own.

What does it mean to lose your sense of agency?

Feeling stuck is often less about lacking ability and more about losing a sense of personal agency, and losing your sense of agency absolutely doesn’t mean you’ve given up. It often means you’ve become so busy responding to life, work or other people’s expectations that you’ve gradually stopped recognising your own ability to choose. 

Perhaps you are out of practise, or perhaps you haven’t yet learned what it feels like to make your own choices, but real empowerment is not about becoming fearless for the sake of it. It is about remembering that you have choices, even when life feels uncertain, and that you get to make them.

Different lives, the same experience

Although people’s circumstances are very different, the emotional experience is often surprisingly similar.

Someone seeking counselling may wonder why life feels flat, despite doing everything they were “supposed” to do.

Someone building a spiritual or creative business may begin to realise they’ve become so focused on the values that drive them that they’ve drifted away from the business of algorithms, visibility or income.

A leader may discover they’re carrying everyone else’s problems while quietly wondering whether there’s a more human way to lead.

On the surface these appear to be very different challenges, but beneath them lies the same question.

How do I become myself?

It is a question that many people ask quietly, often long before they ask for help.

The quiet loss of agency

One of the greatest losses during periods of uncertainty like these is agency. We begin looking outside ourselves for certainty. We might even confuse agency with a lack of confidence.

So we search for the right book.The right coach. The right therapy. The right spiritual practise. The right leadership framework. The right business strategy.

And of course, none of these things are inherently wrong. They can all be enormously helpful. But sometimes we reach a point where we’re simply collecting answers instead of developing trust in ourselves.

Without noticing, we begin believing that everyone else holds the wisdom we lack.

Our own inner voice becomes quieter until eventually we stop asking “What feels true for me?” and start asking “What should I do?”

Now those are very different questions.

The philosophy behind Humanistic Magick

Humanistic psychologist Carl Rogers believed that people possess an innate tendency towards growth when the conditions are right.

Rather than assuming people are fundamentally broken, he believed they already possess remarkable capacity for wisdom, creativity and development. And humanistic magick begins from much the same place.

It doesn’t assume you need rescuing or fixing. Instead, it creates opportunities for reflection, curiosity and, importantly, honest conversation so that you can begin hearing yourself again.

Sometimes that happens through counselling. Sometimes through coaching. Sometimes through reflective journalling, visualisation, tarot, meditation or symbolic ritual.

These practises are not intended to tell you what your future should be. They are invitations to become curious about the person you are becoming. Of course the practises matter in context here, but the relationship you build with yourself is what matters even more.

The journey back to yourself

Real change rarely begins with certainty. In our experience, more often than not it begins with discomfort.

You realise that the life you’ve carefully built no longer fits quite as comfortably as it once did or you realise your life is actually someone else’s dream for you (or themselves!).

Perhaps you’ve outgrown old beliefs. Perhaps you’re questioning long-held assumptions. Perhaps you’ve become tired of performing at work while feeling disconnected from it on the inside.

Recognition can feel unsettling because it asks us to admit that something needs to change before we know what that change looks like (and it’s comforting to have a solution. Even when this is before the problem is really defined). This is why lasting transformation usually happens gradually.

Understanding yourself is only the beginning. Learning how to make different choices takes time. New boundaries feel uncomfortable. New conversations feel risky. New ways of leading can feel unfamiliar. Allowing yourself to rest can feel undeserved. Trusting your intuition after years of ignoring it can feel surprisingly difficult.

But eventually those small decisions begin to accumulate. What once felt like conscious effort slowly becomes part of who you are.

Not necessarily because you’ve become someone different, more because you’ve become fully yourself.

What empowerment really feels like

Empowerment is often misunderstood. Real empowerment is very quiet. It is the over exuberance of confidence that we might assume it to be. 

Empowerment doesn’t always mean feeling positive either. And empowerment won’t remove experiencing doubt.

Real empowerment is noticing you have options where you once believed there were none. It feels like setting a boundary without apologising for existing. It feels like leading with empathy instead of authority. It feels like building a business that reflects your values, yours and your customers’ needs rather than chasing someone else’s definition of what you should be doing. It feels like recognising that uncertainty is part of growth and not evidence you’ve taken the wrong path.

Most of all, empowerment feels like trusting yourself enough to keep making choices that reflect the person you are becoming.

Humanistic magick as a framework for agency

This is the deeper intention behind humanistic magick. Whether you come to us for therapeutic sessions, coaching, leadership development or a spiritual practise, the destination is remarkably similar.

It all leads towards agency.

Not having someone tell you what your future should be, but discovering the confidence (the empowerment) to write more of it yourself.

The work we do is about helping you remember the person who was there before life convinced you that you had no choice.

A simple reflection

Perhaps you’ve become dependent on other people’s approval. Perhaps you’ve convinced yourself that external factors at play hold all the power. Perhaps you’ve simply forgotten how much wisdom already exists within you.

Next time you feel this way, rather than asking yourself “What should I do next?”

Try asking, “Where in my life have I quietly handed my choices over to someone or something else?”

And you don’t need to solve everything today. Sometimes the first step back towards yourself is simply recognising where you’ve wandered away. And perhaps remembering that even now, in this stuck feeling, you absolutely still have choices.

References

Credit where credit is due, we aim to cite our sources because we value truthful content. 1 source was referenced during research to write this content, but you are encouraged to follow our links as well. 

  1. Rogers, C. R. (1961). On becoming a person: A therapist’s view of psychotherapy. Houghton Mifflin.

About Humanistic Magick

Humanistic Magick is a psychology-informed framework developed by Andie Brookes that integrates reflective and symbolic practises to support meaningful, lasting personal change. You can explore the full reference guide here https://magentaschoolofmagick.com/what-is-humanistic-magick/

Thank you for subscribing. By subscribing you now have premiere access to exclusive content. Do you know someone who would like to enjoy all our free content? Please share this with them and invite them to subscribe too!

Authors

  • For spiritually minded people who want to use the tools of magick alongside the techniques and processes found in NLP, hypnotherapy, and psychology in order to create real lasting change in their work and their lifestyle.

    View all posts
  • Andie is an NLP practitioner, certified Life Coach, qualified Hypnotherapist and writer devoted to helping others awaken their inner power through intentional, compassionate change. She combines her training in humanistic counselling and hypnotherapy with a deep personal practise in modern magick. Andie writes about using evidence-based psychology within soulful, magickal living. 

    View all posts

We believe you shouldn’t have to choose between therapy and tarot, psychology and spirituality. At Magenta School of Magick, we weave them together through Humanistic Magick , a compassionate, integrative approach to personal growth and transformation. By signing up you'll receive The Humanistic Magick Weekly. A newsletter delivered every Wednesday. This is your catalyst for inspired change, all in support of improving your work and your lifestyle.

What are your thoughts? Join the conversation by sharing your insights respectfully

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close